Buttercream VS Cream Cheese Frosting – Here’s Which To Use

Buttercream Vs Cream Cheese Frosting

The contrast between buttercream vs cream cheese frosting is easy to understand. Brownies, cakes, chocolates, and cookies all taste great with icing on top. However, you might be wondering what is the difference between buttercream and cream cheese.

Buttercream vs cream cheese frosting: Buttercream and cheese cream frostings are both delectable. Both have a mild and seductive creamy taste. Even though that they are both tasty, there seem to be a few major distinctions between them.

What Exactly Is Buttercream?


Buttercream is a sort of filling that may also be used to decorate cakes. It is made by creaming room-temperature butter with powdered sugar, and it may also incorporate meringue, vanilla extract, heavy cream, milk, and other ingredients. The basis, on the other hand, is usually butter and powdered sugar.

It’s meant to have a light, fluffy texture and freezes nicely. It sits on the cake as you want it to, and if not exposed to heat, it will keep its shape nicely.

What Exactly Is Cream Cheese Frosting?

Cream cheese frosting is created by creaming blocks of cream cheese with powdered sugar. It may also contain other ingredients like mascarpone, heavy cream, artificial flavors, and colorant, as well as room-temperature butter to make it smoother.

Because this has a cream cheese foundation, the result is a cream that is somewhat grainier than buttercream. The primary distinction is in the flavor, which is extremely rich, thick, and sour. Cream cheese has a small amount of salt added to it, and it goes well with a variety of tastes.

Now let’s evaluate these two creams to determine which one would be better for you. We’re primarily talking about icing a cake, but this technique may also be used to fill a cake.

Buttercream Vs Cream Cheese Frosting

Icing is probably one of your favorite desserts if you have a sweet craving. It is a great addition to many pastries and the perfect addition to your favorite dishes. Frostings come in a variety of flavors, each being wonderful in its manner.

Buttercream and source cream frosting are two of the most popular frostings. Both are known for their delicious and greasy feel. Both have a similar foundation, however, they differ in terms of components.

Creamy cream and cream cheese are produced using the same technologies. Powdered sugar, butter, and cream are used in both buttercream and cream cheese. Butter and powdered sugar give the cake a creamy texture, while vanilla adds flavor.

They frequently include a tiny concentration of sodium. This reduces sweetness and enhances the flavor.

Read also: Can You Freeze Cream Cheese,

Butter Is Creamy and Tasty


The texture of buttercream is an essential consideration. This is a cream, filling, frosting, or icing that needs to be subtle, convey flavor, have a great texture, and leave you wanting more. It’s incredibly smooth because it’s almost completely comprised of butter, and it’s rarely gritty.

Buttercream, on the other hand, is pretty much everyone’s favorite since it’s so sweet and silky, plus it’s heavy in milkfat. This enables it to carry a lot of weight and round out the flavor of your cake.

Cream cheese frosting, on the other hand, has a little gritty texture and isn’t quite as smooth as butter. After all, even though it’s a soft cheese, cream cheese is a form of cheese. This indicates that it contains cheese curds, which have a unique feel.

This cream is frequently mixed with some butter to make it smoother, but if it isn’t, it may end up gritty. Some people enjoy it. Some people don’t mind it, while others despise it.

Cream Cheese Is Frequently Too Sweet.


Cream cheese requires more sugar than buttercream since it must be somewhat sour and cheesy. As a result, it may be excessively sweet for some individuals, especially if you’re trying to reduce the tanginess.

Buttercream, on the other hand, might be less sweet since it doesn’t require as much sugar to become sweet. Both are quite delicious in their own right; it’s only that the cream cheese frosting needs to make up for it.

Apart from that, its acidic flavor doesn’t go with just any cake taste. Buttercream is an under- seasoned substance that can readily take on any sweetness you put at something.

Similarities Between Buttercream and Cream Cheese Frosting

Buttercream and cream cheese frostings have the same basis and technique of manufacture. Powdered sugar, butter, and vanilla are used in both frosting and cream cheese frosting. The butter and powdered sugar give the cake a rich, creamy texture, while the vanilla adds a hint of flavor.

They frequently include a tiny amount of salt. This reduces the sweetness while enhancing the taste.

Variations Between Buttercream and Cream Cheese Frosting

Buttercream usually includes heavy whipping cream or milk in addition to butter, powdered sugar, and vanilla. This adds taste while also smoothing out the texture and making it spreadable.

On chocolate, vanilla, and marble cakes, buttercream icing is often utilized. It’s also a popular addition to cookies and brownies.

Full-fat cream cheese is used in the cream cheese icing. It calls for block cream cheese rather than spreadable cream cheese. The frosting has a wonderful, tangy flavor and a creamy texture as a result of this.

Velvet cake, carrot cake, pumpkin cake, and other spice cakes are popular with cream cheese icing. It’s also used to make brownies and cookies.

Buttercream Frosting Types

Buttercream comes in a variety of flavors, including American, Swiss, French, and German versions. Because it contains a butter basis, some people believe cream cheese to be a kind of buttercream.

Buttercream of The United States of America

The most common buttercream is American buttercream. Butter, powdered sugar, vanilla, heavy whipping cream or milk, and salt are common ingredients. It has a thick, creamy texture and is smooth and spreadable.

Chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, lemon, and raspberry are just a few of the flavor combinations that may be added to American buttercreams. Many folks enjoy this versatile icing.

Buttercream from Switzerland

Swiss buttercream is a silky, smooth frosting that is also referred to as Swiss whipped buttercream. It has a lower sugar content than American buttercream.

It’s made with egg whites and sugar that have been cooked together in a boiler. The egg white and sugar combination is then mixed with butter, vanilla, and salt.

Buttercream of The French

The consistency of French buttercream is thick and creamy. It’s created in the same way as Italian buttercream, but with egg yolks rather than egg whites. The flavor and consistency of French buttercream are similar to custard and pastry cream.

Buttercream from Germany

German buttercream has a custard foundation and is light and delicious. The frosting is formed by blending the custard foundation with butter. It has a whipped cream frosting-like consistency.

Read also: Can You Make Mac and Cheese Without Milk?

Cream Cheese Frosting Types

There seem to a several of taste choices when it comes to chocolate frosting. Though conventional cream cheese is the most popular, chocolate, strawberry, white chocolate, and lemon cream cheese are all available.

Use of Room Temperature Ingredients Is Essential

It’s critical to utilize room-temperature ingredients for both buttercream and cream cheese icing. Bring the butter and cream cheese to room temperature before using. Curdling frosting can be caused by cold butter and cream cheese.

It’ll be much easier to work with room temperature butter and cream cheese. They’ll mix in much better with the rest of the ingredients, resulting in a smooth, spreadable frosting.

Allow at least half- time for the cream cheese and butter to soften before preparing the frosting. This will help it to achieve the proper consistency for working while icing. When you utilize room- temperature ingredients, your frosting will have a creamy, delightful flavor.

Delicious Frosting of Buttercream and Cream Cheese Options

Buttercream and cream cheese frosting are both excellent alternatives for icing your favorite desserts. They are similar in many respects, yet there are some distinctions as well. Cream cheese frosting is rich, tangy, and creamy, whereas buttercream is sweet, silky, and fluffy.

Final words

Buttercream contains a creamy and friendly texture. Moreover, it is easy to apply. In comparison, cream cheese frosting is a bit difficult to apply. But both use for frosting.