Best Substitute for Butter in Mac and Cheese

substitute for butter in mac and cheese

Can you make mac and cheese without butter? No need to worry, in this article we will tell you about the ingredients that you can use as a substitute to butter when making mac & cheese.

There is no doubt that mac and cheese is a great dish. People like to eat it as a snack at lunch, dinner or any other part of the day.

Butter is a key ingredient in mac-and-cheese dishes, as the use of butter gives the mac-and-cheese dish a rich flavor and texture.

What happens when you don’t have butter and you want to make mac and cheese?

So, the question arises as to which substitute for butter in mac and cheese can be used.

No need to worry, in this article we will show you several alternatives to butter that you can use as a substitute to butter when making mac and cheese.

By using these alternatives, you will not be able to get a butter-like texture in mac and cheese, but you will definitely be able to make your dish taste better with the help of these ingredients.

Let’s read the details of the ingredients that you can use as a substitute for butter in mac and cheese.

Substitutes for Butter in Mac and Cheese

butter substitute for mac and cheese
butter substitute for mac and cheese

You can use a variety of fats instead of butter, such as margarine, ghee, oil, heavy cream and cream cheese. You can also use vegan as a substitute for butter. Such as nut butter, tahini or homemade peanut butter.

You can also use coconut oil as an substitute. It’s up to you to decide which ingredient to use in mac and cheese as a substitute for butter.

You can use one or more of the above ingredients as a butter substitute. Many of these ingredients will change the final taste of your mac and cheese. But you may like this taste.

Let’s talk about these ingredients now, and find out how they can be used as a butter substitute.


The first and most commonly used butter substitute that vegans rely on is margarine. Let those who do not know about margarine know that it is hardly similar to butter. It is a plant fat called vegan butter.

But it’s not vegan. It is made from vegetable oil and water instead of milk. And it is widely packaged and sold and used in baking and cooking.

When it comes to mac and cheese, margarine works well as an alternative. Not only does it make your dish thick and creamy but it also gives the mac and cheese a buttery flavor.

That is why it is considered a great substitute to butter. Using margarine instead of butter is a great option whether you are a vegan or not. You can get the flavor you are looking for as an alternative to make and cheese.

You can add a little nutritional yeast to in mac & cheese to make its taste better. If you want to make your mac and cheese richer, add heavy cream to it.

Clarified Butter / Ghee

If you do not have butter or you are prohibited from using butter for any reason. Then you can use ghee as a substitute for butter in your food or mac & cheese.

Ghee is obtained by melting butter. It is high in fat but low in oil. That’s why you can use it as a substitute for butter.

Cream Cheese

Depending on the taste, you can use cream cheese instead of butter. It gives your mac & cheese a creamy, thick and delicious taste.

However, if you want to make mac & cheese roux, you can add oil, ghee or margarine.

Heavy Cream

If you want to get rich and lots of calories from mac and cheese. So you have to use heavy cream instead of butter. In fact, butter is also obtained from heavy cream.

You have to put a little heavy cream in a tightly closed container and stir it for a few minutes.

This way the fat and protein components will stick together and you will be able to separate the butter from the heavy cream.

If you don’t like butter, add heavy cream to your mac and cheese. Don’t try to make mac and cheese roux.

Plant-Based Options

If you are looking for a dairy-free substitute to butter, several vegans can be used as a Substitute. Coconut oil works just like butter. So you can use it as an alternative to Mac and Cheese.

Commonly used cooking oil can also be used as a substitute for butter in Mac and cheese.

But it will not give you the same flavor as butter in Mac and cheese. Tahini and peanut butter are very oily and high in protein and fats.

That’s why you can make the dish creamy by using them as a substitute for Mac and cheese. when making roux, use oil to separate the top. When roux is done, rest for a while.

Can I Use Mayo Instead of Butter in Mac and Cheese?

Yes you can also use mayonnaise as a butter substitute in Mac and Cheese. But remember that mayonnaise is commonly used in sauces made for Mac and Cheese.

Whenever you use mayonnaise as an alternative for butter in Mac and Cheese, add cheese to get the flavor. This will make your Mac and Cheese taste better.

How Much Butter to Use as An Alternative.

If you are going to use margarine or clarified butter as a replacement for butter in Mac and Cheese. So you have to add them to Mac and Cheese in the same amount as butter.

Assuming you use six tablespoons of butter in your Mac and Cheese, you should add six tablespoons of ghee or margarine to Mac and Cheese as a substitute.

If you are making boxed macaroni, you can add sour cream, mayonnaise or yogurt. This will give you a creamy texture of Mac and Cheese.

Instead of four tablespoons of butter, you need to use one cup of these ingredients.

If it becomes too oily, add some acidic or starch, so you can add sour cream or cream cheese to it. It will work well. If it dries, add more milk or heavy cream.

Is Butter Really Important for Cooking Mac and Cheese?

The simple answer is yes or no. Because in some situations we use butter in Mac and Cheese. But there are some situations where we don’t use butter in it.

If you are going to make Boxed Mac and Cheese, you will not use butter in it. Because the shelf life of butter is very short.

Most packaged Mac and Cheese are made without butter. In this case butter substitute milk or cream can be used in Mac and Cheese. They make your dish creamy.

Butter has its own flavor. If you don’t want to get that flavor, you can use any substitute in Mac and Cheese.

Many health-conscious people add butter to Mac and Cheese. Because it is more beneficial for health. Boiled pasta is added to packed Mac and Cheese.

When you actually cook packaged Mac and Cheese, you can add butter to it. The use of butter improves the flavor and texture of your Mac and Cheese.

As well as the taste, butter also improves the texture of your dish, so you can add butter to your Mac and Cheese. In addition, the use of butter gives you many fat resources that are good for your health.

What Does Butter Do In Mac And Cheese ?

As we mentioned earlier, the main purpose of adding butter to boxed macaroni and cheese is to give macaroni and cheese extra flavor.

That’s why you can get the richest and best flavor by adding full cream milk or heavy cream to mac and cheese.

However, you can add butter or any fat source to the basic sauce or roux to make homemade mac and cheese.

In addition, butter plays an important role in thickening the sauce. The basic step in making roux is to mix the flour in the heated butter and add milk to it.

Then add cheese and seasoning to this mixture. So that the sauce made for macaroni and cheese is rich and creamy.

Butter also protects your macaroni and cheese from drying out. It keeps your macaroni nice and moist.

If you are curious about food and want to know more facts about food, stay tuned to our website.